Welcome to SOUTHEAST KENTUCKY BEHAVIORAL HEALTH

Tag closure

Why Closure Doesn’t Always Come

Learning to Heal Without the Conversation You Were Hoping For

Article Five: Part of the Healing After Heartbreak Series

You Keep Waiting

You tell yourself that if you could just have one more conversation, everything would make sense. Maybe they would finally explain why they left. Maybe they would apologize. Maybe they would admit they made a mistake. Maybe they would tell you it wasn’t your fault.

So you wait.

You replay imaginary conversations while driving to work. You picture running into them at the grocery store. You wonder what you would say if your phone suddenly rang and their name appeared on the screen. Days become weeks. Weeks become months. Yet the conversation never comes.

If you’ve been waiting for closure from someone else, you are not alone. It is one of the most common places people become emotionally stuck after a relationship ends.

What Is Closure?

Many people think closure is something another person gives us. In reality, closure is something we gradually build within ourselves. Closure is the ability to accept that something has ended, even if every question was never answered. It doesn’t mean you suddenly understand everything that happened or agree with the way you were treated. It simply means you stop waiting for the past to become different than it is.

Unfortunately, many relationships end without the kind of ending we hope for. There is no heartfelt apology. No long conversation that answers every question. Sometimes there isn’t even a goodbye. That uncertainty can be painful because our minds naturally want complete stories. We like beginnings, middles, and endings. When an ending feels unfinished, our brains continue searching for one.

The Mind Hates Unfinished Stories

Have you ever started reading a mystery novel only to discover that the last chapter was missing? You would probably feel frustrated. You might even make up your own ending because your mind wants the story to feel complete. Heartbreak often feels exactly like that. The relationship ended, but the final chapter was never written. Instead of accepting that some pages may always be missing, the brain keeps rereading earlier chapters, hoping it somehow overlooked an answer. The truth is that some stories never receive the ending we wanted. That doesn’t mean the story cannot still teach us something valuable.

The Search for “Why”

One of the first questions people ask after a breakup is, “Why?”

  • Why did they stop loving me?
  • Why didn’t they fight for us?
  • Why did they move on so quickly?
  • Why wasn’t I enough?

These questions are understandable, but they often become a trap. Even when people receive an explanation, it rarely brings the peace they expected.

Imagine someone says, “I just wasn’t happy anymore.” Does that answer every question? Usually not. Instead, the mind asks another question. “But why weren’t they happy?” Then another. “Could I have changed that?” Then another. The search continues because the heart is looking for certainty in a place where certainty no longer exists.

A Story That Might Sound Familiar

Emily spent nearly a year hoping her former fiancé would call. She wasn’t hoping to get back together. She simply wanted him to explain why he had ended the engagement so suddenly. Every time her phone rang, part of her hoped it would be him. One afternoon, nearly eleven months later, he finally called. They talked for almost two hours. He apologized. He admitted he had handled things poorly. He answered every question she had written in her journal.

After hanging up, Emily expected to feel relief. Instead, she cried. Not because the conversation went badly. Because she realized something important. The conversation hadn’t healed her. The healing had already begun long before the phone ever rang. The call didn’t create closure. It simply confirmed the work she had already done.

Closure Is a Decision Before It’s a Feeling

Many people believe they will move forward once they feel ready. More often, the opposite happens. We decide to move forward first. The feelings slowly catch up later. This is true in many areas of life. Someone recovering from surgery doesn’t wait until they feel strong before taking their first steps. They begin walking while they still feel weak because movement is part of healing. Emotional healing often works the same way. You don’t have to stop hurting before you begin living again.

Therapist’s Note

One of the greatest gifts you can give yourself is releasing someone from the job of explaining your worth. Your value has never depended on another person’s ability to recognize it. Some people leave because of your shortcomings. Others leave because of theirs. Either way, your identity is bigger than someone else’s decision.

A Healing Exercise: Write the Ending You Never Received

Tonight, take out a journal and write the conversation you’ve been wishing would happen. Write every question you still wish you could ask. Then, beneath each question, write the answer you need most—not necessarily the answer you think they would give, but the one that helps you move forward with honesty and self-respect. When you finish, read the final paragraph aloud:

“I may never receive every answer I wanted, but I refuse to let unanswered questions prevent me from living the life that is still waiting for me.”

You may find that the words you needed most were always within you.

Final Thoughts

Closure is rarely a single conversation. It is rarely a perfect explanation. More often, closure is something that quietly develops as you continue living. It grows every time you choose peace over obsession. Every time you stop checking your phone. Every time you invest in your own future instead of waiting for someone to return. One day, you may realize that you haven’t thought about them in hours. Then days. Then weeks. Not because you finally received all the answers. But because your life became bigger than your questions. And perhaps that is what closure really is.

About the Author

John S. Collier, MSW, LCSW-S is a Licensed Clinical Social Worker and the Executive Director of Southeast Kentucky Behavioral Health, LLC. With more than 25 years of experience in the behavioral health field, he has worked with individuals, couples, families, and communities facing some of life’s most difficult challenges.

His clinical expertise includes trauma, grief, anxiety, depression, relationship issues, and life transitions. John believes that healing happens when people feel seen, heard, and supported with compassion and respect. He is passionate about translating psychological research into practical tools that empower people to understand their emotions, strengthen their relationships, and build healthier, more meaningful lives.

As a therapist, speaker, and writer, John’s goal is simple: to offer hope, guidance, and practical solutions for real-life struggles. He lives in Southeast Kentucky and is deeply committed to serving his community.

References

Boss, P. (1999). Ambiguous Loss: Learning to Live with Unresolved Grief. Harvard University Press.

Neimeyer, R. A. (2016). Techniques of Grief Therapy: Assessment and Intervention. Routledge.

Worden, J. W. (2018). Grief Counseling and Grief Therapy (5th ed.). Springer Publishing.

American Psychological Association. (2023). APA Dictionary of Psychology: Closure and Rumination.

Series Reminder

Healing doesn’t mean forgetting. It means carrying yesterday without letting it steal tomorrow.

Grieving Someone Who Is Still Alive

When the Person Is Gone from Your Life but Still Walking Through Theirs

Article 4: Part of the Healing After Heartbreak Series

They Didn’t Die. They Just Left.

There is a unique kind of grief that few people talk about. It comes when someone you deeply loved is still alive, still breathing, still going to work, still laughing with friends, still posting pictures online—but they are no longer part of your life.

There was no funeral. No obituary. No gathering where people came together to honor the loss. Instead, there was a text message. A difficult conversation. A signed divorce decree. Or perhaps there was nothing at all except silence.

People around you may expect you to move on quickly because “they’re still alive.” But your heart doesn’t measure loss by whether someone is living. It measures loss by absence. It knows that the person who once shared your mornings, your dreams, your holidays, and your future is suddenly gone from your everyday life. That absence is real. And it deserves to be grieved.

A Different Kind of Grief

Most people understand the grief that follows death. Society has rituals for it. Friends send flowers. Employers offer bereavement leave. Neighbors bring meals. There is an understanding that healing will take time.

Relationship loss is different.

Often, people tell you to “get over it,” “find someone else,” or “everything happens for a reason.” While those words may be well-intentioned, they can unintentionally minimize a very real loss. Psychologist Pauline Boss introduced the concept of ambiguous loss, describing situations in which someone is physically present but psychologically or emotionally absent from our lives (Boss, 1999). Although her work often focused on families dealing with dementia, addiction, or missing loved ones, the concept also helps explain why the end of a significant relationship can feel so confusing. The person still exists, but the relationship you once depended on does not. Your heart struggles because there is no clear ending.

There is simply…absence.

You Aren’t Just Grieving a Person

When relationships end, we often believe we are grieving only the individual. In reality, we are grieving much more than that. You are grieving the future you imagined.

You are grieving the traditions you thought you would build together. The vacations you planned but never took. The anniversaries that will never be celebrated. The conversations you assumed you would have twenty years from now. Sometimes the deepest pain isn’t remembering what happened. It’s realizing what will never happen. That realization can feel overwhelming because it requires letting go of a future that once felt certain.

Imagine This

Imagine spending months planning the home of your dreams. You carefully choose the floor plan, the paint colors, and where the furniture will go. You picture birthdays around the dining room table, Christmas mornings in the living room, and quiet evenings on the back porch. Then, just before construction begins, the project is canceled. The house never exists. Yet you still grieve it.

Why?

Because your mind had already begun living there.

Relationships work the same way. Long before the future arrives, we emotionally move into it. We begin decorating it with hopes, dreams, and expectations. When the relationship ends, it isn’t just today’s happiness that disappears. It is the imagined future that disappears with it.

Why Certain Moments Hurt So Much

One of the most confusing parts of healing is that grief often arrives without warning. You may be doing well for several days, feeling hopeful and optimistic, when suddenly you hear your song playing in a restaurant. A familiar cologne passes by in a crowded store. Someone laughs exactly the way they did.

In an instant, your emotions rush back. Many people interpret these moments as setbacks. They aren’t.

Our brains naturally connect emotions to sights, sounds, smells, and places. Those memories become part of the brain’s filing system. When something familiar appears, it temporarily reopens that file. That doesn’t mean you are moving backward. It simply means your brain remembers. Over time, those emotional reactions usually become less intense, even though the memories remain.

A Story That May Feel Familiar

After twelve years of marriage, Robert found himself eating dinner alone for the first time in decades.

For weeks, he continued setting two plates on the table before catching himself. Every Friday evening he automatically drove toward the neighborhood where they used to meet friends for dinner. He wasn’t consciously trying to relive the past. His life had simply followed those routines for so many years that his mind continued them without asking permission.

One evening, instead of driving to the familiar restaurant, he stopped at a small local café he had never visited before. He brought a book, ordered something different, and sat quietly by the window. It wasn’t a magical moment. He still missed her. He still cried on the drive home. But something important happened that evening.

For the first time since the separation, he created a memory that belonged only to him. Healing often begins that way—not with dramatic breakthroughs, but with small moments that slowly become the foundation of a new life.

Therapist’s Note

One of the greatest misconceptions about grief is believing that healing means you stop loving someone. It doesn’t. You can appreciate what a relationship once meant while also accepting that it no longer belongs in your future. Acceptance is not betrayal. Acceptance is giving yourself permission to keep living.

A Healing Exercise: Saying Goodbye to the Future You Imagined

Tonight, find a quiet place with a journal or a blank sheet of paper. Write a letter—not to the person—but to the future you thought you were going to have. Describe the life you imagined together. Write about the dreams, the plans, the traditions, and the milestones that now feel lost. Don’t worry about grammar or saying the “right” thing. Simply let your heart speak honestly. When you finish, begin a second paragraph with these words:

“Although that future is gone, I still have the opportunity to create a meaningful life, and my next step is…”

Complete the sentence. Don’t try to write the rest of your life story. Just write the next step. Healing rarely requires us to know the entire journey. It simply asks us to take the next faithful step.

Final Thoughts

Perhaps the hardest part of grieving someone who is still alive is accepting that closure rarely arrives the way we hope it will. Sometimes there is no final conversation. No apology. No explanation that suddenly makes everything make sense. Sometimes healing begins when we stop waiting for someone else to provide closure and begin creating it ourselves. Your story did not end because this relationship did. There are still chapters left to write. New friendships to build. New places to explore. New laughter waiting to be discovered. And one day, when you look back, you may realize that while losing them changed your life, it did not define it. Your future is still waiting.

About the Author

John S. Collier, MSW, LCSW-S is a Licensed Clinical Social Worker and Executive Director of Southeast Kentucky Behavioral Health, LLC. With more than 25 years of experience in behavioral health, grief counseling, and relationship therapy, he has helped countless individuals navigate loss, rebuild their lives, and discover hope after heartbreak. His writing combines evidence-based psychology with compassionate, practical guidance to help readers heal one step at a time.

References

Boss, P. (1999). Ambiguous Loss: Learning to Live with Unresolved Grief. Harvard University Press.

Boss, P. (2006). Loss, Trauma, and Resilience: Therapeutic Work with Ambiguous Loss. W. W. Norton & Company.

Neimeyer, R. A. (2016). Techniques of Grief Therapy: Assessment and Intervention. Routledge.

Worden, J. W. (2018). Grief Counseling and Grief Therapy (5th ed.). Springer Publishing.

Series Reminder

Healing doesn’t mean forgetting. It means carrying yesterday without letting it steal tomorrow.

When the Door Closes Before the House Collapses: How a Breakup May Have Saved You

Few experiences in life hurt as deeply as the end of a relationship. Whether the relationship lasted months or decades, a breakup often feels less like losing a partner and more like losing the future you had imagined. You don’t just grieve the person—you grieve the vacations that never happened, the holidays you pictured together, the home you imagined building, and the life you believed was just beginning.

In the midst of that pain, it is nearly impossible to consider that the breakup may not have been the worst thing that happened to you. It may have been the best. Not because the relationship meant nothing. Not because your love wasn’t real. But because sometimes the greatest blessing in our lives first arrives disguised as rejection.

We Often Mourn Potential More Than Reality

One of the most painful aspects of heartbreak is that our minds naturally fill in missing pieces with hope. Psychologists refer to this as idealization—a tendency to remember the positive aspects of someone while minimizing or overlooking significant problems (Murray et al., 1996).

After a breakup, our brains frequently replay:

  • The best conversations.
  • The happiest memories.
  • Their smile.
  • Their laugh.
  • The way they looked at us.

What we often forget are:

  • The inconsistent communication.
  • The emotional distance.
  • The broken promises.
  • The anxiety.
  • The uncertainty.
  • The nights spent wondering where we stood.

Our memories become edited highlight reels instead of accurate documentaries.

Love Shouldn’t Require Constant Convincing

Healthy relationships certainly require effort. They require forgiveness. They require compromise. But they should not require someone to repeatedly convince another person to stay. If someone continually leaves you questioning your worth…If you constantly have to prove you’re enough…If your security depends on someone else’s changing emotions…Then the relationship has quietly become survival rather than partnership.

Research consistently shows that secure relationships are characterized by reliability, responsiveness, and emotional safety rather than chronic uncertainty (Mikulincer & Shaver, 2016). Love isn’t supposed to feel like an audition.

Imagine Five More Years

Heartbreak narrows our vision. Instead of asking:

“Why did they leave?”

Ask yourself:

“What if they hadn’t?”

Imagine spending another five years:

  • Walking on eggshells.
  • Wondering whether today would be the day they changed their mind.
  • Ignoring your own needs to preserve the relationship.
  • Accepting less than what you deserved because losing them felt worse than losing yourself.

Many people aren’t grieving because they lost something healthy. They’re grieving because they almost settled for something unhealthy.

The Red Flags You Ignored Become the Lessons You Keep

After enough time passes, many people begin noticing something remarkable. The very behaviors they once excused become obvious warning signs. Perhaps they:

  • Avoided difficult conversations.
  • Refused accountability.
  • Made you responsible for their happiness.
  • Frequently withdrew affection.
  • Used guilt instead of communication.
  • Left you feeling anxious more often than peaceful.

These aren’t simply personality quirks. Many represent patterns associated with lower relationship satisfaction and emotional instability if left unresolved (Gottman & Silver, 2015). Pain has a remarkable ability to remove rose-colored glasses.

Rejection Often Reveals Incompatibility

One of the greatest misconceptions about breakups is believing that if someone leaves, you somehow failed. Sometimes that’s true. Often, it isn’t. Sometimes two good people simply want different lives. Different priorities. Different values. Different levels of commitment. Trying to force compatibility where it doesn’t naturally exist only delays inevitable pain. Compatibility is not measured by chemistry alone. It is measured by whether two people consistently choose each other.

The Relationship Didn’t Fail Overnight

Most breakups don’t begin on the day someone says goodbye. They begin months—or even years—earlier. Communication slowly decreases. Affection changes. Resentment quietly grows. Needs stop being expressed. Small disappointments accumulate into emotional distance. The breakup simply becomes the final chapter of a story already being written. Recognizing this doesn’t erase the pain. It helps explain it.

Sometimes the Person You Miss Isn’t the Person Who Left

This realization is often one of the hardest. You may not actually miss the person who ended the relationship. You may miss:

  • Who they used to be.
  • Who you hoped they’d become.
  • The version of the relationship that existed in your imagination.
  • The future you believed you were building together.

Those aren’t the same thing. Grieving a dream is every bit as painful as grieving a person.

What You Actually Dodged

It’s easy to think:

“I lost the love of my life.”

But perhaps you avoided:

  • A marriage filled with resentment.
  • Years of emotional loneliness.
  • Constant insecurity.
  • Repeated betrayals.
  • Living with someone who was never fully committed.

Imagine discovering those realities after buying a house together. After having children. After twenty years. Sometimes heartbreak isn’t evidence that life is punishing you. Sometimes it’s life protecting you before your roots grow too deep.

Healing Changes the Story

Right now your heart tells you:

“I lost everything.”

Healing eventually whispers:

“I lost someone who wasn’t willing or able to continue building this life with me.”

Those are very different statements. One is despair. The other is acceptance. Acceptance doesn’t erase grief. It simply allows hope to return.

A Final Thought

One day you may look back and realize that the breakup you begged God to prevent became the moment that redirected your life toward something healthier. The relationship ending doesn’t necessarily mean you weren’t enough. It may simply mean the relationship wasn’t. You didn’t dodge love. You dodged years of wondering whether you were loved enough. And while today that feels like loss…

Tomorrow, it may become the greatest act of protection your life has ever received.

About the Author

John S. Collier, MSW, LCSW-S is a Licensed Clinical Social Worker, behavioral health clinician, and Executive Director of Southeast Kentucky Behavioral Health. With more than 25 years of experience helping individuals and families navigate trauma, grief, relationships, and personal growth, he writes to bridge clinical research with real-life emotional experiences. His work encourages readers to find resilience, embrace healthy relationships, and discover hope even in life’s most difficult seasons.

References

Gottman, J. M., & Silver, N. (2015). The Seven Principles for Making Marriage Work (Revised ed.). Harmony Books.

Mikulincer, M., & Shaver, P. R. (2016). Attachment in Adulthood: Structure, Dynamics, and Change (2nd ed.). Guilford Press.

Murray, S. L., Holmes, J. G., & Griffin, D. W. (1996). The benefits of positive illusions: Idealization and the construction of satisfaction in close relationships. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 70(1), 79–98. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.70.1.79

Slotter, E. B., Gardner, W. L., & Finkel, E. J. (2010). Who am I without you? The influence of romantic breakup on the self-concept. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 36(2), 147–160. https://doi.org/10.1177/0146167209352250